The company used Midjourney to generate the promotional images.
Richard Whiddington,
When San Francisco Ballet designed its promotional posters for this year’s performance of Nutcracker, it opted not to recruit a renowned photographer or celebrated illustrator, but Midjourney, the A.I. image generator.
The pair of images it released ahead of its three-week December run—one of a bug-eyed mouse emerging out of darkness, and the other of a cork and cloth soldier wearing a macabre expression—were supposed to shake up the traditional aesthetics associated with the ballet.
Instead, the images plunged the 90-year-old company into the heart of a raging debate between artists and A.I. image generators.
The charge is simple. By choosing Midjourney rather than a working artist, SF Ballet appears to be endorsing the theft of artist intellectual property upon which A.I. image generators are built.
“So disappointing to see that an organization in the arts is using A.I. art and actively harming visual artists,” wrote one user in the comment section of SF Ballet’s post on Instagram. “A.I. art in its current form uses work from artists without their consent, credit, or compensation.”
In response, SF Ballet claims it was simply experimenting with new technology in partnership with advertising agency Butler, Shine, Stern & Partners, something one might expect of a company based at the heart of America’s technology ecosystem.
A post shared by San Francisco Ballet (@sfballet)
“Nearly 30 designers, producers, and creatives from local advertising agency contributed to our Nutcracker campaign, which offers us a chance to experiment with today’s technological tools,” a SF Ballet spokesperson told Artnet News via email. “We employ hundreds of San Francisco artists on our stages, in our orchestra pit, and behind the scenes every season, including in the creation of our marketing campaigns, and we look forward continuing to do so in the future.”
Although few prominent public-facing institutions have used A.I.-generated images as prominently as SF Ballet, the development has added further anxiety to artists who are seeing the unchecked expansion of services such as Lensa A.I., DALL E 2, and Dream Studio (which runs on open sourced Stable Diffusion).
Although the technology underpinning the generators isn’t new, the ease of use—as simple as typing a descriptor into a search box—has seen their popularity explode in the past 12 months. Intellectual property regulation has yet to catch up.
“I’m an illustrator but also I’ve worked in theatre for nearly a decade,” read another comment on SF Ballet’s post on Instagram. “A.I. ‘art’ is an insult to visual artists and hurts us all in the art world. Consider hiring an artist who is alive who has hard-earned skills.”
Following the backlash, it seems likely SF Ballet will return to working with living, breathing artists in the future.
“SF Ballet remains deeply connected to and proudly a part of the diverse artistic communities of the Bay Area,” the institution said.
Read the Year’s Most Popular Stories:
After More Than 50 Years, Reclusive Artist Michael Heizer Is Finally Ready to Unveil ‘City,’ His Life’s Work. Here’s What It Looks Like
A College Grad Paid $75 for an Illuminated Manuscript Page After Realizing It Was From a 700-Year-Old Prayer Book He’d Studied in Class
A Man Broke Into the Dallas Museum of Art and Smashed Ancient Greek Artifacts Because He Was ‘Mad at His Girl’
Scholars Have Decoded the World’s Oldest Sentence Written With an Alphabet. It’s a Highly Specific Warning… About Lice
A College Student Bought a $10 Ashtray at a Goodwill. Turns Out It’s a Yoshitomo Nara—and He Flipped It for a 30,000 Percent Profit
Share
By Richard Whiddington
By Richard Whiddington
By Dorian Batycka
By Artnet News in Partnership With Maestro Dobel Tequila
By Sarah Cascone
©2022 Artnet Worldwide Corporation. All Rights Reserved. ';
$('body').append(ouibounceScript);
// Add animation css
addCss('https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/animate.css/3.5.2/animate.min.css');
if (generalSettings.loadFontAwesome) {
addCss('https://maxcdn.bootstrapcdn.com/font-awesome/4.7.0/css/font-awesome.min.css');
}
// Check if ouibounce exist before calling ouibounce
var initOuibounce = setInterval(function() {
if (typeof ouibounce !== 'undefined') {
appendNewsletterSignup();
var $modal = $('#ouibounce-modal');
SignupForm.init($modal.find('form'), function onSuccess() {
//hide form fields and show thank-you message
$modal.find('.form-row').hide();
$modal.find('.newsletter-signup-thank-you').fadeIn('fast');
setNewsletterCookie('signedUp', 1);
//after successful signup, hide the signup bar after 5 seconds
setTimeout(function() {
closeSignupBar();
}, 5000);
});
// Handler for close signup button
$('body').on( 'click', '.close-signup', function(){
setNewsletterCookie('closedSignupBar', 1);
closeSignupBar();
});
ouibounceAPIaccess = ouibounce(
$modal[0], {
aggressive: true,
sensitivity: 50,
callback: function() {
slideInModal('Down');
}
}
);
clearInterval(initOuibounce);
}
}, 100);
}
function slideInModal(upOrDown) {
$('#ouibounce-modal')
.removeClass('slideOutDown slideOutUp')
.addClass( 'slideIn' + upOrDown );
setNewsletterCookie('recentlyShown', 1);
}
function setNewsletterCookie(cookieName, value) {
//exdays*24*60*60
var settings = cookieSettings[cookieName];
var expirationMinutes = settings.expiration_minutes;
if (!expirationMinutes) {
expirationMinutes = daysToMinutes(settings.expiration_days);
}
setCookie(cookieName, value, expirationMinutes);
}
function daysToMinutes(numDays) {
return numDays * 24 * 60;
}
/**
* Generic setCookie() method, used by setNewsletterCookie().
* There is probably no need to call this directly - use setNewsletterCookie().
*/
function setCookie(cname, cvalue, expMinutes, prefix) {
//default prefix is 'artnet_newsletter_'
if (prefix == undefined) {
prefix = 'artnet_newsletter_';
}
var d = new Date();
d.setTime(d.getTime() + (expMinutes*60*1000));
var expires = "expires="+d.toUTCString();
//console.log(prefix + cname + "=" + cvalue + ";" + expires + ";path=/");
document.cookie = prefix + cname + "=" + cvalue + ";" + expires + ";path=/";
}
function getCookie(cname, prefix) {
//default prefix is 'artnet_newsletter_'
if (prefix == undefined) {
prefix = 'artnet_newsletter_';
}
var name = prefix + cname + "=";
var ca = document.cookie.split(';');
for(var i = 0; i
artnet and our partners use cookies to provide features on our sites and applications to improve your online experience, including for analysis of site usage, traffic measurement, and for advertising and content management. See our Privacy Policy for more information about cookies. By continuing to use our sites and applications, you agree to our use of cookies.
You are currently logged into this Artnet News Pro account on another device. Please log off from any other devices, and then reload this page continue. To find out if you are eligible for an Artnet News Pro group subscription, please contact [email protected]. Standard subscriptions can be purchased on the subscription page.
Log In
